Carrier Status Watch · Guides

New entrant safety audit: what FMCSA checks and the 16 automatic failures

A new interstate carrier is monitored by FMCSA for 18 months as a new entrant. During that time FMCSA runs a safety audit, generally once the carrier has been operating for at least 3 months (49 CFR 385.307). The audit reviews driver qualification, hours of service records, vehicle maintenance, the accident register and drug and alcohol testing (385.311), and any one of 16 violations fails it automatically (385.321).

Check a USDOT number now (free)

What the audit reviews (385.311)

It looks at your safety management systems and a sample of required records. The audit itself doesn't give you a safety rating; ratings follow a compliance review (385.317).

The 16 automatic failures (385.321(b))

ViolationRuleFails on
No alcohol or drug testing program382.115(a) or (b)One occurrence
Using a driver with an alcohol concentration of 0.04 or more382.201One occurrence
Using a driver who refused a required test382.211One occurrence
Using a driver known to have tested positive382.215One occurrence
No random testing program382.305One occurrence
Knowingly using a driver without a valid CDL383.3(a) or 383.23(a)One occurrence
Letting a driver operate with a disqualified permit or CDL383.37(b)One occurrence
Letting a disqualified driver drive383.51(a)One occurrence
Operating without the required minimum insurance387.7(a)One occurrence
Operating a passenger vehicle without the required minimum insurance387.31(a)One occurrence
Knowingly using a disqualified driver391.15(a)One occurrence
Knowingly using a physically unqualified driver391.11(b)(4)One occurrence
Not requiring drivers to keep a record of duty status395.8(a)51% or more of records examined
Operating a vehicle declared out of service before repairs396.9(c)(2)One occurrence
Not fixing out-of-service defects a driver reported before operating396.11(a)(3)One occurrence
Using a vehicle that hasn't been periodically inspected396.17(a)51% or more of records examined

You can also fail without one of these if the audit finds you lack the basic safety management controls in appendix A to part 385 (385.321(a)).

Pass or fail notice

If you fail: the fix window

What can bring the audit sooner (385.308)

Refusing the audit, and the end of the 18 months

If you refuse the audit, FMCSA sends notice that registration will be revoked unless you agree in writing within 10 days; otherwise revocation and an out-of-service order take effect on the 11th day (385.337).

If you've had the audit and aren't under an out-of-service or corrective action order when the 18 months end, FMCSA removes the new entrant designation and tells you in writing that your registration is permanent (385.333).

What we can and can't check

Audit results aren't in the public data we read, so we can't tell you whether you've had one. We can watch the public record items that matter during the 18 months: insurance on file against the amount required (operating without it is automatic failure 9), BOC-3, authority and USDOT status. Run the free five-point check on your USDOT number, or get it every day. We never file for you.

Related

Sources, read November 20, 2026: eCFR: 49 CFR part 385, subpart D, New Entrant Safety Assurance Program (current through November 17, 2026). The regulations are the official rule; this page is a plain-English summary, not legal advice. Not a government website. Carrier Status Watch reads public records and sends reminders; we never file anything for you.

Built by Playground Giants.